Welcome to the new look Pocket-lint.co.uk

3 "Skypephone" mobile phone Will this change mobile phones forever?

Reviewer
Stuart Miles
Review Date
6 November 2007
Manufacturer
3
Price as reviewed
£50
Latest price
compare

Our score

7/10 7/10 See more with this score

Reader score

5/10 5
  • rss
  • pdf
  • share
  • save
  • email
  • print

Full review

6 November 2007 - The mobile phone is changing, mobile network operator 3 would have you believe. But is it for the better? We take a look at the company's new Skype phone and see whether this is the future of mobile phone calls.

Skype as you probably know is an enhanced messaging service that comes complete with video calling, chat, the ability to phone mobile or landline phones with SkypeOut and installed on 246 million computers around the world.

The trouble is that you'll be stuck in your home if you want to use it. Skype has managed to break away from the computer in recent years with dual supporting landline handsets from the likes of Philips and Netgear, but never beyond a Wi-Fi connection, until now.

In steps the Skype phone from 3, a mobile phone that has a dedicated Skype button so you can phone your Skype contacts when you are out and about.

The black handset is fairly basic. Made by Chinese firm Amoi, it has a "Sony Ericsson" feel about it, a large screen, large simple keypad and light on the applications.

Hardware-wise it has a 2 megapixel camera, a dedicated camera button, an application switcher button and your usual volume controls. You'll also get a 256MB card in the box.

Software-wise there is an MP3 player, games, web browser and 3's Launcher app that gives you shortcuts to sites like YouTube and Facebook.

Very much a case of don't expect too much and overall the phone is well-built, simple, but effective in its performance.

Taking centre stage is that dedicated Skype button directly under the screen.

Being a Skype product, the idea is that it's always on, so once you've created an account or simply logged in, you're always online whenever the phone is switched on.

So what of performance? Well it's business as usual. You log in, get your list of Skype contacts and then start making your calls. If you are already logged in on your PC or Mac, this acts as a second connection and you can choose which one you answer when they both ring.

If you're a regular user of Skype you won't notice any difference from making a call from your PC or Skype-enabled landline. The quality is good, but not crystal clear.

Calls aren't completely unlimited however as they are on the PC application and 3's Skype package allows you to make 4000 minutes of calls as long as you top up your account with £10 every month. The £10 doesn't go towards the calls so you get voice as well, but if you don't top it up you loose the ability to make Skype calls.

Within that tariff you'll also get 10,000 chat messages although you'll have to be a good texter as the Skype phone doesn't feature a QWERTY or 20-key keyboard.

So what's the catch? Well frustratingly you won't get video calling, even though it's a 3G handset and that's the main selling point from both companies of their services. You'll also miss out on the ability to SkypeOut to other mobiles or landlines or be able to use the Skype function when roaming aboard if you aren't in a 3 territory.

Interestingly for the more geeky amongst you, 3 actually makes the first step of the call as a voice call into the Skype network rather than going data all the way.



Verdict

If you are a big Skype user then the chance to take your contacts with you will be really appealing, offering you 2 hours of free calls every day to other Skype users.

If you are just looking for a regular phone without any whistles or bells, then this is certainly worth taking a closer look at, however for most it will be a disappointment beyond the Skype button.

Mobile workers will feel especially cheated as there is virtually no smartphone features available here.

3 say they will be offering the Skype service on other handsets, but clearly this is their push for the service.

Good, but too basic an offering to want to replace your latest Samsung, Nokia or Sony Ericsson handset.

Sign up and write a review » Want it » Own it »



Comments

  • Personally, the idea of a mobile phone with Skype appealed. My home [landline] phone is permanently forwarded to my Skype-In number. My wife works in China and we use Skype to communicate when she is away from home in the UK. The loss of the ability to Skype-Out at VoIP rates to international mobiles and landlines appeared a small price to pay as long as I could receive both my mobile calls and my Skype calls without being tied to my desk [and PC] whilst at work or away from home.

    The reality is that things have not quite worked as planned. Whether it is the quality of the signal reception on the handset or the lack of signal strength from 3™ I am not in a position to ascertain but when ever I walk into ANY building [home, office or local pub] I loose service! The only way I can get this phone to work is to walk out into the open air which is of no use whatever to me.

    Indecently, a friend of mine with a normal (3) mobile phone has the same problem which leads me to believe it is the either the coverage or signal strength of the mobile phone service provider. I have never had this problem with my existing mobile phone provider.

    I had the opportunity to transfer my existing mobile phone number from a different service provider at the time of purchase but refrained from doing so until I had tested the product. I am pleased I did not as at least I can still receive my mobile calls on my existing phone without being consigned to my back garden or a park bench.

    I feel cheated out of the £49.99 purchase price and the offending phone is now consigned to the bin!
    Posted by Mark Doig, United Kingdom
  • I use skype on my laptop without any major problems and bought a skype wifi phone for use in my house. there is some delay and the quality of sound not perfect with this phone. the volume is not very high, which may be one issue.

    Just downloaded the skype 3G smartphone mobile app however, which seems to be VERY slow on 3G. worthlessly so. so taking skype mobile in it's true sense doesn't appear to be there yet.
    Posted by Graham, United States
  • Worst phone i've ever had tbh. No signal in buildings, calls cutting off mid-way when i do get signal, duplicate text messages arriving on my phone all day, randomly turning off. I could go on. Customer services were no help at all. I cant wait to see out my contract with 3. Posted by Joe, England
  • wierdly enough i have had the exact same problems as joe form england duplicat texts bad signal randomly turning off and taking about 15mins to turn on. Thier customer service is terrible, i get no help from them or have they ever repaired my phone. i know at least 4 people who have left 3 and more who want too. If you want my advice DONT BUY A SKYPE PHONE. its a waste of money. Posted by john , england
  • so pleased its not just me, buying the skype phone has been a costly mistake! in addition to the points above I would add that the battery life is terrible and the phone generates such a magnetic field it will pick up 1p coins and blanks hotel key cards! Posted by john, England
  • is this phone worth getting for 40 pound Posted by jhanzeeb, england
  • does it have blue tooth Posted by navodhya, england
  • I like the fact that it is light. small and simple. However I now have a massive problem: the memory is constantly full which means that I can't receive text messages anymore. I deleted everythin on the phone, but it still says there was no memory. Something is wrong. Very annoying! Posted by Konrad, UK

(Will not be published)

  (Next time sign in to bypass ReCaptcha)

Broadband?

Compare 50+ deals available to you

Powered by Top 10 Broadband

Pocket-lint.co.uk poll

Q. Is the new Nintendo DSi a waste of time?

Vote YES Vote NO

» LAST TIME
When asked Will your next phone have a touchscreen? 58% said yes and 42% said no